Banks by state
Safest banks in Ohio
- Quarter ending
- June 30, 2026
- Source
- FDIC Call Reports
- Results
- First 50 results
Scores from 0 to 100 compare banks within separate groups based on total assets. The state lists sort these scores; “Safest” is not an absolute ranking of risk or a recommendation. Trust institutions, which manage assets for others, and banks that do not lend remain included. Their business models can affect reported ratios.
Ranked banks
If content extends beyond view, scroll sideways. For keyboard scrolling, focus the table or chart and use arrow keys.
| Bank | Score | Grade | Peer group | Assets |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rank 1Guardian Savings BankWest Chester | 98.8 | Grade A | $1B to under $10B | $1.39B |
| Rank 2Versailles Savings and Loan CompanyVersailles | 97.3 | Grade A | Under $300M | $65.6M |
| Rank 3First Federal Savings and Loan AssociationDelta | 97.2 | Grade A | Under $300M | $246M |
| Rank 4The Covington Savings and Loan AssociationCovington | 97.1 | Grade A | Under $300M | $84.0M |
| Rank 5The Brookville Building and Savings AssociationBrookville | 95.7 | Grade A | Under $300M | $41.2M |
| Rank 6Greenville National BankGreenville | 94.8 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $641M |
| Rank 7Union Savings BankCincinnati | 93.8 | Grade A | $1B to under $10B | $4.02B |
| Rank 8The Settlers BankMarietta | 93.4 | Grade A | Under $300M | $142M |
| Rank 9The First Central National Bank of St. ParisSt. Paris | 93.1 | Grade A | Under $300M | $97.0M |
| Rank 10Credit First National AssociationBrook Park | 92.7 | Grade A | Under $300M | $39.8M |
| Rank 11The Equitable Savings and Loan CompanyCadiz | 92.7 | Grade A | Under $300M | $8.59M |
| Rank 12The St. Henry BankSt. Henry | 92.3 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $436M |
| Rank 13The Bank of Magnolia CompanyMagnolia | 92.2 | Grade A | Under $300M | $108M |
| Rank 14Erebor Bank, N.A.Columbus | 91.9 | Grade A | $1B to under $10B | $4.66B |
| Rank 15Nationwide Trust Company, FSBColumbus | 91.6 | Grade A | Under $300M | $154M |
| Rank 16The Ottoville Bank CompanyOttoville | 91.3 | Grade A | Under $300M | $93.8M |
| Rank 17United Midwest Savings Bank, National AssociationDegraff | 91.1 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $523M |
| Rank 18Sutton BankAttica | 89.5 | Grade A | $1B to under $10B | $1.74B |
| Rank 19The Pioneer Savings BankCleveland | 89.2 | Grade A | Under $300M | $54.7M |
| Rank 20The First Citizens National Bank of Upper SanduskyUpper Sandusky | 88.9 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $390M |
| Rank 21Fairfield Federal Savings and Loan Association of LancasterLancaster | 87.5 | Grade A | Under $300M | $281M |
| Rank 22Third Federal Savings and Loan Association of ClevelandCleveland | 87.3 | Grade A | $10B to under $100B | $18.1B |
| Rank 23The Andover BankAndover | 86.6 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $595M |
| Rank 24Home Savings Bank of WapakonetaWapakoneta | 86.3 | Grade A | Under $300M | $45.3M |
| Rank 25The Peoples Bank Co.Coldwater | 85.8 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $859M |
| Bank | Score | Grade | Peer group | Assets |
| Rank 26The Home Loan Savings BankCoshocton | 85.8 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $387M |
| Rank 27Fidelity Federal Savings and Loan Association of DelawareDelaware | 85.8 | Grade A | Under $300M | $132M |
| Rank 28The Harrison Building and Loan AssociationHarrison | 84.8 | Grade A | Under $300M | $268M |
| Rank 29The Farmers & Merchants State BankArchbold | 84.2 | Grade A | $1B to under $10B | $3.49B |
| Rank 30Liberty BankIronton | 84.1 | Grade A | Under $300M | $55.7M |
| Rank 31Civista BankSandusky | 84.0 | Grade A | $1B to under $10B | $4.29B |
| Rank 32Conneaut Savings BankConneaut | 84.0 | Grade A | Under $300M | $76.7M |
| Rank 33Spring Valley BankWyoming | 83.6 | Grade A | Under $300M | $114M |
| Rank 34First Bank of OhioTiffin | 83.3 | Grade A | Under $300M | $278M |
| Rank 35Belmont Savings BankBellaire | 82.9 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $613M |
| Rank 36The Mt. Victory State BankMount Victory | 82.8 | Grade A | Under $300M | $23.4M |
| Rank 37The Park National BankNewark | 82.5 | Grade A | $10B to under $100B | $12.6B |
| Rank 38The Farmers State BankNew Madison | 81.5 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $330M |
| Rank 39The Hocking Valley BankAthens | 81.2 | Grade A | $300M to under $1B | $354M |
| Rank 40The Waterford Commercial and Savings BankWaterford | 78.7 | Grade B | Under $300M | $60.0M |
| Rank 41The Richwood Banking CompanyRichwood | 77.7 | Grade B | $1B to under $10B | $1.30B |
| Rank 42First National Bank in New BremenNew Bremen | 76.4 | Grade B | $300M to under $1B | $467M |
| Rank 43The Peoples Savings and Loan CompanyWest Liberty | 76.4 | Grade B | Under $300M | $110M |
| Rank 44Minster BankMinster | 76.1 | Grade B | $300M to under $1B | $812M |
| Rank 45The Fort Jennings State BankFort Jennings | 75.7 | Grade B | Under $300M | $286M |
| Rank 46Community First Bank, National AssociationForest | 74.8 | Grade B | Under $300M | $56.3M |
| Rank 47Miami Savings BankMiamitown | 73.3 | Grade B | Under $300M | $148M |
| Rank 48The State Bank and Trust CompanyDefiance | 72.9 | Grade B | $1B to under $10B | $1.61B |
| Rank 49First State BankWinchester | 71.8 | Grade B | $1B to under $10B | $1.24B |
| Rank 50Portage Community BankRavenna | 71.1 | Grade B | $300M to under $1B | $552M |